My 6-Year-Old Son Who Thought Excitement Was Cruelty
"MAMA, I THINK I'M A BULLY"
What I Learned When My 6-Year-Old Confused Reading Aloud With Cruelty
He climbed into my bed at 6:40am on a Wednesday.
Not unusual. My son is six. He still believes morning cuddles are a human right.
But his face stopped me.
Not sleepy. Not whiny. Not hunting for my phone to watch something.
Ashamed.
"Mama," he whispered into my shoulder. "I think I'm a bully."
Fourteen years as an educator. Hundreds of bullying cases. Countless parent meetings. Behaviour policies. Restorative justice training.
And my own child just diagnosed himself as the villain.
"Why do you think that, habibi?"
"Because yesterday at story time, I read louder than everyone. And the teacher said my voice was too loud. And she looked tired. And I kept being loud anyway."
He pulled the duvet over his head.
"I bullied my teacher, Mama."
THE GAP BETWEEN INTENTION AND LANGUAGE
Here's what my son meant:
"I was excited about the story. I forgot to regulate my volume. My teacher corrected me. I felt guilty immediately. I don't know the word for 'accidentally annoying someone' so I used the only word I know for 'making someone feel bad.'"
Here's what he said:
"I am a bully."
Here's what I almost did wrong:
I almost laughed.
I almost said "No, sweetheart, that's not bullying, that's just being loud."
I almost kissed his forehead and sent him to breakfast, his shame unnamed and unresolved.
But I caught myself.
Because here's the truth we don't talk about enough:
Children inherit our vocabulary long before they understand our definitions.
We've done an incredible job teaching children the word bully.
We've taught them bullying is bad.
We've taught them to report it.
But have we taught them the gradient?
THE VOCABULARY CHILDREN ACTUALLY NEED
| Behaviour | What It Actually Is | Is It Bullying? |
|---|---|---|
| Reading too loud | Excitement + poor volume control | ❌ NO |
| Interrupting accidentally | Impulsivity | ❌ NO |
| Being rude once | Bad day, forgot manners | ❌ NO |
| Having a conflict | Disagreement between two people | ❌ NO |
| Being mean once | A mean moment | ⚠️ BORDERLINE |
| Being mean repeatedly | Pattern of unkindness | ✅ YES |
| Targeting the same person daily | Targeted cruelty | ✅ YES |
| Attacking someone's identity | Bias-based bullying | ✅ YES |
🧠 A child who can say "I had a mean moment" is a child who can change. A child who only knows "bully" either collapses in shame or deflects in denial.
They know bully. It's a clean, sharp, scary word.
They don't know impulsive. They don't know unaware. They don't know accidental versus intentional.
So when a 6-year-old reads too loud, he doesn't say:
"Mama, I struggled with volume modulation today."
He says: "I'm a bully."
THE OTHER CHILDREN
I thought about my son's confession all the way to work.
Then I walked into my office and thought about the other children.
The ones who actually bully.
The ones who deliberately exclude.
The ones who repeatedly mock accents, lunchboxes, family backgrounds.
Do they also lack the vocabulary?
Are there children sitting in my behaviour meetings who genuinely believe they're just "joking" or "being funny" because no one ever taught them the specific words for what they're actually doing?
Yes. Absolutely yes.
I have sat across from a 15-year-old boy who spent six months sending cruel memes to a classmate.
When I asked him why, he said: "It was just banter. I didn't mean it like that."
He didn't have the word for what it was.
He didn't know targeted harassment. He didn't know pattern of cruelty.
He knew banter. He knew joking. He knew funny.
And no adult had ever given him better words.
WHY THIS GAP MATTERS
A child who cannot name their behaviour cannot change it.
A child who only knows "bullying" as one big scary thing will either:
1. Over-identify— like my son. They carry shame that was never theirs to carry. They label themselves villain for accidental loud reading. They apologise for existing.
2. Under-identify— "I'm not a bully, I just joke." They never reflect. They never stop. Because no one gave them the word for what they're actually doing.
Both are failures of adult precision.
We spend so much time teaching children what not to do.
We spend almost no time teaching them what to call what they just did.
WHAT I SAID TO MY SON
I pulled the duvet down. Held his face. Six years old, still soft around the edges.
"Habibi, do you know what bullying actually is?"
He shook his head.
"Bullying is when you choose someone and hurt them on purpose, again and again, even when they ask you to stop. It's not an accident. It's not excitement. It's not one time. It's a pattern of choosing cruelty."
"So I'm not a bully?"
"You are a boy who got excited about a story and forgot to use his quiet voice. That's not bullying. That's being six. And tomorrow, you'll practice remembering."
He nodded. Relief flooded his face.
Then he asked the question I'll never forget:
"Mama, why did my teacher say it was bullying then?"
She didn't.
She said "Your voice is too loud."
He heard "You are a bully."
And that gap — between what adults say and what children hear — is where so much of our anti-bullying work either lives or dies.
WHAT WE CHANGED
This conversation broke something open in me.
So I took it to my team.
1. THE VOCABULARY GRADIENT
Every child from age 6 upward now learns to distinguish:
THE VOCABULARY GRADIENT
📍 Every child from age 7 upward now learns to distinguish:
| Word | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Accident | I didn't mean it, it happened once | "I accidentally knocked your bag." |
| Rudeness | I forgot my manners | "I interrupted you. That was rude." |
| Conflict | We both disagree | "We both want the same chair. Let's solve it." |
| Mean moment | I hurt someone on purpose, once | "I called you a name. That was mean. I'm sorry." |
| Repeated meanness | I keep doing it after being asked to stop | "This is the third time. I need help to stop." |
| Bullying | I choose someone and hurt them on purpose, again and again | "I target this person daily. I don't stop when they cry." |
A child who can say "I had a mean moment" is a child who can apologise and move forward.
A child who only knows "bully" either collapses in shame or deflects into denial.
A child who can say "I had a mean moment" is a child who can apologise and move forward.
A child who only knows "I'm a bully" either collapses into shame or deflects into denial.
THE THREE QUESTIONS
Before any behaviour report crosses my desk, the student answers:
1. What did you do?
(Facts only. No "but he started it." No "it was just banter.")
2. What word would you use to describe it?
(Accident? Rudeness? Conflict? Mean moment? Bullying?)
3. What do you think the other person felt?
(Hurt? Embarrassed? Alone? Scared?)
This takes three minutes.
False reports have dropped. Genuine confessions have tripled.
Because children finally have permission to be specific.
WHAT PARENTS CAN ASK TONIGHT
Stop asking: "Was anyone mean to you?"
It's too vague. Children don't know what "mean" means anymore.
Try these instead:
🗣️ "Did anyone make you feel small today?"
🗣️ "Did you have a mean moment you want to fix?"
🗣️ "Did you see someone else being left out?"
🗣️ "What word would you use for your day?"
🗣️ "Did you accidentally hurt anyone's feelings?"
Parents who've tried this tell me their children talk more in one car ride than they have in months.
Because specific questions invite specific answers.
WHAT TEACHERS CAN SAY TOMORROW
When a child confesses something "bad" they did:
"It's fine, don't worry about it."
(Shame dismissed but unnamed.)
"Thank you for telling me. What word are we using for what happened?"
(Shame acknowledged and given a name.)
Then give them better words if they need them.
THE SENTENCE I'LL NEVER FORGET
My son is six.
He thought reading too loud made him a bully.
But here's what else he did:
He told me.
Not because he was caught. Not because he was in trouble. Not because a teacher reported him.
He told me because his chest was heavy with guilt and he trusted me to name it.
How many of our children carry that same weight?
How many confessed to a parent or teacher and were dismissed with "That's not bullying, don't worry about it"— their shame unnamed, their confusion unresolved?
How many never confessed at all?
A FINAL CONFESSION
I've spent fourteen years teaching children what bullying IS.
I haven't spent enough time teaching them what bullying ISN'T.
That changes now.
Not because my son is perfect.
Because he came to me with a heavy heart and the wrong word — and my job wasn't to correct his word.
My job was to honour his heart.
YOUR TURN
💬 What's a word your child used wrong that broke your heart a little?
💬 Have you ever had a "mean moment" you wish you could take back?
💬 What question actually gets your child talking?
Drop a comment. I read every single one.
If this resonated:
👉 Share it with one parent who needs better words tonight.
👉 Save the vocabulary table — screenshot it, pin it, use it.
👉 Follow for more honest parenting and real talk from inside the classroom.
P.S. I showed this to my son before publishing.
He read it slowly. Sounding out the big words.
Then he looked up and said:
"So I'm not a bully. I'm just learning."
Yes, habibi.
That's exactly what you are.
Comments
Post a Comment